I don't understand the part about not having a game we focus on as a guild simply because not everyone might want to play it. I dont think the idea was to kick out everyone who didnt play or anything drastic.

In fact, one could argue that since there is rarely a really *great* games out that appeal to everyone, that having a competitive MMORPG guild not maintaining a presence
in any game for over 2 years is kind of silly.

There are also several free games out and about that are relativly decent compared to other games on the market.

All that being said, I'm still kind of split on the idea myself, but I can see the point of it.