Quote:


Your saying that secret installations at every metropolitan backbone are required to listen in legally on overseas conversation?

Dont think so. Targeted eavesdropping was taking place long before this period, and certainly didnt need Narus STA 6400's on every switching station. The NSA has probably had listening equipment at the stations that transport overseas for some time. They also tap into oceanic fiber lines via submarine. Theres no need to build a secret listening station in friggin Iowa to listen in on Al Queda overseas.




Not a telecon expert, so I can't say definitively, but in looking over the article again, the big clue is in the name given to the piece of equipment in question: "Semantic Traffic Analyzer".

That sounds like they may have software sniffers looking for keywords, like maybe 'Jihad', 'bomb-making', etc, for possible domestic terrorism survellance, or maybe even keywords like 'robbery', 'counterfeit', or 'child pornography' for simple law enforcement. That kind of monitoring has been conducted legally for years, even as far back as 'gasp' Bill Clinton, or even Jim-meh Carter. If you don't like that, well, don't plan your next bank robbery via email.
Quote:


I'll read the article that argues it was a proper decision tommorow. I'll give you the benifit of the doubt here until I get time to look it over.

And as for the last, are you seriously going to make an argument that invading Iraq was a good idea, despite the fact that if we had not, we would be in a much better position diplomatically and militarily to do something about Iran?



Yes it was a good idea, if only from a humanitarian standpoint (300,000+ in mass graves discovered so far, last time I checked, plus rape rooms and children's prisons closed), and also from a regional/national security standpoint.

For those who haven't been keeping up with current events, here is a link to an account involving the recent translation of an interesting Iraqi government document. For those who don't care to follow the link, here's a Reader's Digest version: the document is from an Iraqi Air Force General to all units requesting for volunteers for suicide missions against American "interests", the timing of the memo appears to fit into a disturbing sequence in the months prior to 9/11. This memo is dated March 17, 2001, less than six months prior to the coordinated al-Qaeda attack on the US, at a time when the Iraqi Air Force was effectively grounded due to the restrictions imposted by the UN sanctioned No Fly zones, and the AQ plotters and pilots appeared to be in close proximity to Iraqi intelligence agents in Europe.

Now what kind of suicide missions could grounded pilots perform?

Questions that make you go, "hmmmmmmmm".
Quote:


I doubt they would have had the guts, had we not mired ourselves in Iraq.




Our decision to invade Iraq was not predicated on future developments in Iran. I know hindsight is 20/20, but asking for prophetic foresight is a bit much for even me to swallow. Be that as it may, it may be handy to have a Marine Expeditionary Division and divisional Army Infantry/Armor/Aviation assets, as well as /USAF tactical/strategic forces close at hand if the National Command Authority decides it need to bring pressure to bear on the Mullah's, don't you think?

Quote:


The point I was making is that unnecesarry wars havent helped our position in dealing with the real problems. This would be the President's decision, and he is the one accountable.


"Let me know if you are confused about other little things that are bothering you..."

Unfortunatly in order to clear up "misunderstandings" and allieviate confusion, something relevant is usually required.

I'm not saying your principles of "hunt the bad guys and kill them" are wrong Owain, far from it. But I really do think you give our current leadership far to much credit, both in the areas of competance and intent.




I think you give them too little credit, but then, that's just me, and nearly 30 years military experience, both on active duty Air Force, and in civilian defense related work, so, take my word for it, or not, but I'm not blowing smoke.


To the everlasting glory of the infantry...

Owain ab Arawn
KGB Supreme Knight
King's High Council