The KGB Oracle
Posted By: Derid Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/21/12 05:20 PM
http://www.gallup.com/poll/157589/distru...ign=syndication

People in general seem to be wising up.

In related news, Dems are far more likely than GOPers or Independents to still have faith in the BS they are shoveled.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/21/12 05:46 PM
I still not sure if anything on the left comes close to FOX.
Posted By: Derid Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/21/12 07:01 PM

While Fox doesnt exactly have a sterling rep in many regards, my take was that even though its known that GOPers watch a lot more Fox.. they know better than to actually trust it.

Anecdotally speaking, most of the GOPers I know who watch Fox dont really trust it - not the way people trusted Edward Murrow or Walter Cronkite. Its true they do watch it because it is more ideologically friendly...

Ofc there are still that 30% who drink the kool-aid.
Posted By: Kaotic Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 06:39 AM
Originally Posted By: sinij
I still not sure if anything on the left comes close to FOX.
Because real impartial journalists all have "thrills up their legs" when Obama speaks...
Posted By: Derid Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 03:36 PM

I dont think its even about partial or impartial.Everyone has a bias of some sort. The problem with the MSM is they do not even attempt to dig for information or provide critical analysis.

On some occasions they will air "competing claims" , but only when it suits them.

Very rarely is there any attempt to cross examine the "claims" - the term "claims" in this context meaning anything put forward by any party - from an AP Wire story to a politicians statement. Its not even the journalists though - the people who decide what stories to run with, how to present them, and whether to dig for context or evaluate its merits does not fall to the journalists.

Those activities are handled by the Editors, Producers, and Executive Producers. Of course like in any job, the lower ranks of talking heads and field reporters and writers quickly learn to produce the types of materials their bosses want to see. The Editors, Producers and Executive Producers of course report to top executives.. and work to produce the type of material *their* bbosses want to see.

The irony of the whole situation is, is that the Maddows and Hannities of the world actually - by MSM standards - do some of the best reporting. Of course sometimes they screw the pooch and mis-report. But the openly biased media at least has incentive to search for stories and cross examine some claims - even if they only apply that rigor to their ideological and political foes.
Posted By: Wolfgang Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 04:46 PM
Originally Posted By: sinij
I still not sure if anything on the left comes close to FOX.


Sorry friend, but you are delusional!
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 04:57 PM
Originally Posted By: Wolfgang


Sorry friend, but you are delusional!


That might as well be the case, but it doesn't prevent me from being right in this particular instance.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 05:01 PM
Originally Posted By: Derid
Everyone has a bias of some sort. The problem with the MSM is they do not even attempt to dig for information or provide critical analysis.


I assume you believe MSM to be "FOX equivalent" on the left?

Alright, I will take your charge of "not providing critical analysis" and raise to FOX intentionally misrepresenting facts to support their make-believe story. I don't object to FOX because they present Right-Side point of view, I object to FOX because they manufacture or intentionally misrepresent facts to manufacture what sells - faux outrage. They are clearly in entertainment/money making business, not in business of keeping people informed, and the irony of this situation does not escape me.

Why would you even bother defending FOX?
Posted By: Kaotic Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 05:44 PM
Originally Posted By: sinij
Alright, I will take your charge of "not providing critical analysis" and raise to FOX intentionally misrepresenting facts to support their make-believe story. I don't object to FOX because they present Right-Side point of view, I object to FOX because they manufacture or intentionally misrepresent facts to manufacture what sells - faux outrage. They are clearly in entertainment/money making business, not in business of keeping people informed, and the irony of this situation does not escape me.

I think you're making the mistake of lumping the opinion shows on fox in with the news shows on fox.

The biggest difference, other than ideologically, between Hannity (I can't stand that condescending ass) and Maddow is that one claims to be opinion and the other claims to be news.

You laid a pretty serious claim there about manufacturing facts. Care to back that up?
Posted By: Derid Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 06:46 PM
Originally Posted By: sinij
Originally Posted By: Derid
Everyone has a bias of some sort. The problem with the MSM is they do not even attempt to dig for information or provide critical analysis.


I assume you believe MSM to be "FOX equivalent" on the left?

Alright, I will take your charge of "not providing critical analysis" and raise to FOX intentionally misrepresenting facts to support their make-believe story. I don't object to FOX because they present Right-Side point of view, I object to FOX because they manufacture or intentionally misrepresent facts to manufacture what sells - faux outrage. They are clearly in entertainment/money making business, not in business of keeping people informed, and the irony of this situation does not escape me.

Why would you even bother defending FOX?


The rest of the MSM manufactures and willfully ignores facts just like Fox. I am not defending Fox... I am pointing out that the rest arent any better.

Things like Zimmerman tapes.. which were edited to sound racist, reporting that the Libyan and Egyptian flare ups were spontaneous protests despite all evidence, etc, etc

Thats without even getting into things that are factual, but presented in a way intended to be misleading. My favorite example being Jets Frontline episode on TARP. The journalists did not lie outright, they just allowed the people they covered to lie without critical cross examination, presented a package that created a false consensus and ignored any alternative views.

Yeah, Fox has many faults. But the rest of the MSM is no better.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/22/12 09:16 PM
Originally Posted By: Kaotic
You laid a pretty serious claim there about manufacturing facts. Care to back that up?


a. They fought FCC policy against the intentional falsification of news. The attorneys for Fox argued the First Amendment gives broadcasters the right to lie or deliberately distort news reports on the public airwaves.

b. Watching fox news have a negative impact on people's current events knowledge (PDF)

c. They Photoshop pictures of people they don't like (no, this isn't Onion)


d. They mislabel Republican scandals as Democrats

e. They outright hysterical about Obama. Example - Obama Administration "Answers To The Quran First And To The Constitution Second"

There is a website that tracks FOX "journalistic creativity". Read if you want day-to-day examples.

http://foxnewslies.net/
Posted By: Daye Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/24/12 03:45 PM
If you hate the Democrats, you read / watch Fox News.

If you hate the Republicans, you read / watch CNN.


They ALL have some sort of political spin on them because they ALL are owned by a tiny minority. Our media in general are owned by a very few parent companies.

Since the folks at the top of those companies have their own political views, it only stands to reason that those under them will simply be broadcasting what they want to you see or hear.


You want a happier life ?

Quit watching / reading the news for anything outside of the weather.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/24/12 04:25 PM
This is false equivalence.

Group A says sky is red, Group B says sky is blue, since they are both biased the sky must be purple.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/24/12 08:37 PM
Originally Posted By: Kaotic
You laid a pretty serious claim there about manufacturing facts. Care to back that up?


Watch this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=km4BfW2836Y
Posted By: Kaotic Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/24/12 10:03 PM
I stopped watching at second 2 when I saw it was Jon Stewart. If this is where you're getting your news, then there is absolutely no point talking to you.
Posted By: Sini Re: Gallup Poll on trust in Mass Media - 09/24/12 10:54 PM
No I don't regularly watch him (or any TV for that matter), but he is right in that video. Whatever you might think of him, even broken clock is right...

If you are allergic, watch starting at 6 minutes. He stops with comedy and starts talking.
© The KGB Oracle